MANGANESE TOXICITY IN BURLEY TOBACCO
ISSUED: 6-66
REVISED: 5-73
J. H. Smiley, W. O. Atkinson and Ira E. Massie
Department of Agronomy
Importance and Symptoms
Manganese toxicity is a major disease
of tobacco in Kentucky. This disease causes plants to grow slowly following
setting, turn light green or yellowish between the larger veins, and gradually
develop numerous dead spots, particularly in the older leaves. This disease
is often so severe that the plants are badly stunted or killed, thus reducing
yield and quality. Occasionally, however, plants recover and develop a
normal green color in the younger leaves later in the season. Manganese
toxicity can be easily prevented, but once it occurs in the field, little
can be done for that crop.
Cause
Manganese toxicity and soil acidity
go hand in hand. As the soil becomes more acid, greater amounts of manganese
are available, and the tobacco plants take up more than they need for normal
growth. Soil pH 5.0 - 5.5 is the critical level for manganese availability.
When the soil pH is 5.5 or higher, trouble from manganese toxicity seldom
occurs, but at 5.0 or lower, toxicity in tobacco is very likely. Between
pH 5.0 - 5.5, toxicity may or may not cause trouble in any particular year.
When a soil becomes acid, not only
does the amount of available manganese increase with resulting manganese
toxicity, but the availability of other important nutrients such as phosphorus,
nitrogen, and potassium is reduced. Figure 2 shows that a soil with pH
above 5.8 gives the greatest availability of major plant nutrients.
Figure 2
With losses of such nutrients as calcium
or magnesium, the soil becomes more acid; however, a main cause of soil
acidity is the use of nitrogen fertilizers such as ammonium nitrate, ammonium
phosphate, ammonium sulfate, urea, and anhydrous ammonia. The degree that
ammonium nitrate changes soil pH in a silt loam soil and the persistence
of such changes are shown in Table 1. The same amounts of phosphorus and
potassium were applied in all cases.
Thus, Table 1 shows that heavy applications
of a nitrogen fertilizer can increase soil acidity so much that many nutrients
are less available to plants. Organic matter (manure, cover crops, tobacco
stalks, etc.) also increases soil acidity upon rotting, but to a lesser
degree than ammonium fertilizers.
Table 1 -Degree of pH Change by Applying Ammonium Nitrate
Pounds Ammonium Nitrate per acre |
Date of Soil Sampling
|
April 25* |
May 7 |
June 6 |
July 3 |
Aug. 2 |
pH |
0 |
5.75 |
5.75 |
5.85 |
5.65 |
5.40 |
375 |
5.90 |
5.45 |
5.35 |
5.25 |
5.10 |
750 |
5.40 |
5.25 |
4.80 |
4.75 |
4.70 |
1500 |
5.50 |
5.05 |
4.85 |
4.50 |
4.70 |
*Before fertilizer was applied on same date.
CAUTION: These are experimental plots and the high rates of nitrogen
are not recommended for crop production.
Prevention
Prevention of soil acidity is the best
control of manganese toxicity. Your best approach is to follow a planned
rotation. A grass or a grass-legume sod is usually best in a tobacco rotation.
Ideally, you should not grow tobacco in the same field more than 2 years
in a row. After each year following tobacco, take a representative soil
sample. If the pH of this soil sample is below 5.8, apply limestone based
on your soil test.
Control
If manganese toxicity has become a
problem and enough land is available, you will want to lime the soil after
the tobacco crop and seed the field to a grass or grass-legume mixture
for at least 3 years before returning to tobacco. In the meantime, the
lime will have reduced the available manganese, and the sod will have improved
the structure of the soil.
If manganese toxicity becomes a severe
problem and you don't have enough land to follow a planned rotation, you
can apply part of the needed limestone following tobacco harvest; disk
it in to insure thorough mixing with the soil. Then the following spring
after the field is plowed, apply the rest of the limestone and disk in
prior to setting the tobacco. This limestone, properly mixed with the soil,
should prevent the toxicity for several years in all but very severe cases.
Don't Overlime
Sometimes growers get such excellent
responses to liming that they begin to apply too much limestone. Excessive
liming will reduce the availability of both phosphorus and potassium and
most of the trace elements. Apply only enough limestone necessary for the
legumes in a tobacco-sod rotation. You can take soil tests once or twice
during each rotation to see just how much limestone is needed.
If the soil test shows the soil to
be moderately to strongly acid, you may have to apply 2 or more tons of
limestone per acre for the good stand of grass and legumes needed to improve
the soil for tobacco.
For land you have in continuous culture,
determine lime and fertilizer needs by taking a good representative soil
sample every year as soon as the tobacco is harvested.